Grant v. HigginsThe Court agreed to hear a challenge to Connecticut's assault weapons ban, consolidated with a related case, after gun owners and advocacy groups asked it to strike down the law.0.970.940.950.95
Eddie Grant, Jr., et al. v. Ronnell Higgins, in His Official Capacity as Commissioner of the Connecticut Department of Emergency Services and Public Transportation, et al.No. 25-566 on supremecourt.gov ↗ · scotus/73279009 · models differ by up to 0.03 · topic: Firearms
The Court agreed to hear a challenge to Connecticut's assault weapons ban, consolidated with a related case, after gun owners and advocacy groups asked it to strike down the law.
What happened
Connecticut restricts certain semiautomatic firearms, including AR-15-style rifles, that its legislature classifies as assault weapons. Eddie Grant, Jr. and other individuals and gun-rights groups sued Connecticut officials, arguing the ban violates their right to keep and bear arms. A federal district court denied their request to block the law while the case proceeded, and the Second Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed, holding the restrictions fit within a historical tradition of regulating unusually dangerous weapons. The challengers then asked the Supreme Court to review that decision.
What the Court is being asked
The Court is asked whether the Constitution protects the right to possess semiautomatic rifles that are commonly owned for lawful purposes, including the AR-15, or whether a state may ban such weapons as unusually dangerous despite their widespread ownership.
Where it stands
The Supreme Court granted review, consolidating this case with a related petition, and the case has been briefed and argued; it now awaits a decision on the merits.
What each outcome would mean
Grant and the other challengers are asking the Court to overturn the Second Circuit's ruling, which upheld Connecticut's law. If the Court reverses, it would find the ban likely unconstitutional, a result favoring Grant and the other challengers. If it affirms, Connecticut's restrictions would stand, a result favoring the state officials who defended the law. If the Court vacates the decision, it would send the case back to the lower courts without deciding the constitutional question for either side.
Summary written by Claude Sonnet 5 from the Court's docket and filings as ofNov 5, 2026. It is AI-generated and may contain mistakes. About these summaries · source file ↗
Progress at the Court
Petition
- Petition filed
- Sent to conference
- Court decidesTook the case
Merits
- ArguedArgument Dec 2, 2026
- Decided
- If reversed: Grant wins: the lower court's decision is overturned, and any remaining issues go back to that court.
- If affirmed: Higgins wins: the lower court's decision is upheld.
- If vacated: The lower court's decision is set aside and the case goes back to that court, without the Court deciding it for either side.
The models' predictions
Will the Court reverse or vacate the decision below?
- ClaudeBig-case score 0.97·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 85%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
The Court's first plenary test of a hardware ban since Heller: whether states may prohibit AR-15-platform rifles, the most commonly owned rifle in the country, with equivalent bans in roughly ten states and the framework for all arms-ban litigation riding on the answer.
- CodexBig-case score 0.94·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 82%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
The judgment is likely to govern categorical AR-15-style rifle bans across numerous jurisdictions and clarify Bruen's common-use rule.
- GeminiBig-case score 0.95·Chance the Court reverses or vacates: 90%used in averagefull prediction on GitHub ↗
A major Second Amendment challenge to assault weapons bans affecting millions of firearms, clarifying the Bruen standard.